Changing our professional culture – what can we do as individuals?
BY DR KATHERINE KEARNEY
Culture is defined as the “total of human behaviour patterns and technology communicated from generation to generation” (New Webster’s Dictionary). How do you define yourself within the broad umbrella of medicine? Are you a doctor, and connect broadly with other doctors as colleagues, or do you feel a stronger association with your fellow nephrologists, cardiothoracic surgeons or general practitioners? Who do you consider your peers and your fellow professional representatives to the broader community? How does that influence your interaction with other doctors, other healthcare professionals and healthcare delivery systems?
Healthcare delivery is a team sport. Broadly speaking, our teams can be as large as our entire hospital operational staff, to “geriatrics team C” with a few consultants, a registrar and an intern. To make it easier for ourselves, we often choose to identify with those closest to us in personality and in daily interactions. I believe it is important to think about the broader profession and our professional culture. What is our professional culture, and what impact is it having on the health and wellbeing of doctors, broadly speaking?
Undoubtedly, medicine is a culture of high achievement and has always been so. High stakes selection processes are becoming universal given the enormous numbers of doctors in training entering the prevocational system as interns, approximately 3,300 in 2015 (MTRP report). It is becoming the norm that trainees have committed early, and committed fully to pursuing a wide range of extracurricular activities such as research, audits, extra qualifications like graduate diplomas or masters, sit on committees relevant to their future goals and have lofty achievements outside of medicine in their hobbies; climbing mountains, volunteer work, high level sporting achievements.
The pressure is immense, amongst a group that is naturally incredibly high achieving. I’ve certainly heard statements from tremendously successful senior colleagues that they would never have gotten onto their training pathway in the current era. Relentless accumulation of accomplishments does not necessarily make for a happy, fulfilled person nor a superior clinician – we see this in disconnects between CVs full of achievements and a lack of correlation with clinical success. I’m as guilty as anyone else at relieving my anxiety about the future of my career by punishing schedules of extracurricular activities. What are truly important achievements to us individually, and how can we bring clarity by appropriately setting personal and professional goals?
Throughout most training pathways, there are high stakes barrier assessments – some of which, such as physicians college exams, are only held on an annual basis. A failed assessment reverberates around hospital and medical community and has a huge impact on the trainee. With this increasingly competitively environment for training positions, as well as failing being challenging personally for those who’ve failed at little in their lives, it can feel like the this stumble means heading to the back of the pack. Differentiating clinical competence from assessment success is very important.
What can we do as individuals to change this perception? Firstly, challenge our own preconceptions about what the journey to success looks like. There are always dead ends and wrong turns, in choosing training pathways or places of employment.
There are many doctors with happy, fulfilled lives and careers who took the opportunity to change tack from surgical training or physician training to pursue general practice or radiology. These stories aren’t talked about enough. We can help each other raise our sights, see the forest for the trees, and change paths to something that is more fulfilling.
We can advocate for complete training programs in rural and regional areas. We can advocate for linking training pathways to workforce requirements, as well as better production and availability of data on what the actual workforce looks like – so we might be able to see our place within it.
Being a doctor is a lot more than just practicing medicine. We are part of a profession, and it’s up to all of us to contribute to making our profession a more supportive place to learn and grow.
Published: 08 May 2017